Cleveland Classic 1 2009
As far as underrated putters go, this one is probably it. Cleveland? They make putters?
Yes, yes they do. In fact, they made this. I believe at the time, 2009, it was around 69 bucks retail for one of these bad boys. How cheap is that?! Jerry Kelly used it back then, and it was a hit. 69 dollars for a putter that a tour pro was using? Please, please sign me up.
For me, I was fortunate enough that my girlfriend bought this for me as as gift. And what a gift! This putter is ridiculously sleeper. The feel on it is parallel with many Scottys, and I have 4 Scottys. Even with the harshest ball (think range ball), it still maintains a firm, but soft, feel. Feedback is excellent. The face is very nicely milled. Because the putter is so soft, it can get dinged up easily. I take care of my clubs, and the act of putting on and off the headcover, putting it in and out of my bag, etc., have left my putter with really small tiny nicks and stuff. Disappointing, but inevitable. At the end of the day, my putter is in clean condition, and I will never get rid of this thing. I go through drivers, putters, irons, but I will never go through this particular putter. I like taking it out now and then to remind me how good this putter stands up against the best, against 300 dollar Scotty Camerons.
I actually had a Cleveland Classic 2, which was the heel shafted model. Kinda like the Odyssey Phil is using now, but Cleveland, and single-colored. However, I sold it to an online store and regret it to this day. It is hard to find these putters in excellent condition nowadays, which is a shame. In my opinion, the newer line from Cleveland just simply does not stand up to this 2009 line. I honestly have nothing negative to say about this putter, except that it was very underrated, and Cleveland could have done more to spice it up. One of my best and most favorite putters ever. Simply put.